Please rotate your device to landscape mode to view the table.


Impact Area Impact Expected by Supporters View by Supporters on the Perceived Desirability of this outcome Impact Expected by Opponents View by Opponents on the Perceived Desirability of this outcome Nature of Disagreement
Industry Control Greater government control and oversight Positive, allows for better regulation and strategic planning Loss of private sector autonomy and decision-making Negative, stifles innovation and efficiency 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Economic Efficiency Improved coordination and resource allocation Positive, can address market failures and externalities Reduced competition and lack of profit incentives Negative, leads to inefficiency and waste 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Employment Job security and stability for workers Positive, protects workers' rights and livelihoods Potential job losses and overstaffing Negative, reduces job flexibility and productivity 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Prices and Affordability Lower prices and increased affordability Positive, improves access and social welfare Potential for higher prices and supply shortages Negative, reduces consumer choice and quality 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Government Revenue Increased revenue from industry profits Positive, provides funds for public services and investment Potential for financial losses and inefficient management Negative, burdens taxpayers and limits private investment 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Political Influence Reduced influence of private industry interests Positive, aligns decision-making with public interest Increased risk of political interference and corruption Negative, undermines meritocracy and accountability 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Innovation and R&D Increased investment in strategic sectors Positive, can drive long-term growth and technological advancement Reduced incentives for private sector innovation Negative, stifles entrepreneurship and competition 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Foreign Investment Potential deterrent for foreign investment Acceptable trade-off for national self-sufficiency Significant deterrent for foreign investment Negative, limits access to capital and expertise 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability