Please rotate your device to landscape mode to view the table.


Impact Area Impact Expected by Supporters View by Supporters on the Perceived Desirability of this outcome Impact Expected by Opponents View by Opponents on the Perceived Desirability of this outcome Nature of Disagreement
Economic Development Significant boost to developing economies Positive, promotes long-term growth and stability Limited impact due to mismanagement and corruption Negative, ineffective use of resources 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Poverty Reduction Substantial reduction in global poverty Moral imperative to help the less fortunate Limited effect on systemic poverty issues Resources could be better used domestically 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Health and Education Improved access to healthcare and education Positive, fosters human development Limited impact due to mismanagement Negative, ineffective use of resources 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Diplomatic Relations Strengthened ties with recipient countries Positive, promotes international cooperation Potential for resentment and dependency Negative, undermines self-reliance 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
National Security Increased stability in developing regions Positive, reduces potential for conflict Limited impact on security concerns Negative, resources could be better used on defense 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Domestic Economy Potential for increased trade and investment Positive, opens new market opportunities Diversion of resources from domestic projects Negative, impact on taxpayers and public spending 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Global Influence Increased soft power and global leadership Positive, promotes national values and interests Limited influence compared to economic powers Negative, resources could be better used domestically 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Environment and Sustainability Support for sustainable development projects Positive, protects shared global resources Limited impact due to weak enforcement Negative, domestic environmental concerns prioritized 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability


Impact Area Impact Expected by Supporters View by Supporters on the Perceived Desirability of this outcome Impact Expected by Opponents View by Opponents on the Perceived Desirability of this outcome Nature of Disagreement
Government Spending Decrease in government spending Positive, reduces budget deficits and national debt Decrease in government spending Negative, undermines efforts to assist developing nations 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
International Relations Weakening of ties with aid recipient countries Acceptable, focus should be on domestic issues Significant damage to diplomatic relationships Negative, harms global cooperation and influence 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Economic Development Limited impact on domestic economy Positive, funds can be redirected to domestic priorities Negative impact on economies of aid recipient countries Negative, hinders economic growth and stability in developing nations 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Humanitarian Assistance Reduction in aid for disaster relief and crisis response Acceptable, focus on domestic needs first Significant reduction in aid for vulnerable populations Negative, exacerbates human suffering and global challenges 2) Agree on impact, disagree on desirability
Global Security Limited impact on domestic security Positive, funds can be redirected to national defense Increased instability and conflict in aid recipient regions Negative, undermines efforts to promote global security 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Soft Power and Influence Decreased influence in aid recipient countries Acceptable, focus on domestic priorities Significant reduction in global influence and soft power Negative, harms ability to shape international norms and policies 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact
Immigration and Refugee Issues Limited impact on domestic immigration Positive, reduces incentives for migration Increased migration and refugee flows from affected regions Negative, exacerbates humanitarian crises and strain on host nations 1) Disagree on extent of expected impact